Part I: For Plaintiffs
I used to be the guy who tried to do everything. The guy who tried to empathize with the client in a tough situation. Who came in solemnly and – as I thought at the time – respectfully, even reverentially. It seemed like the right approach – that’s how I could meet people where they were, right? And a lot of folks – mediators among them – do that now.
A few years ago I realized that there are limits to what even the best mediator can or should do. I can’t fix what has happened. I can’t say I’ve been through what you’re going through, or even that I understand how deeply your pain runs. I’m just a person, like you, and I’ve had my own life’s journey. To pretend that I know what you’re experiencing does a disservice to both of us.
See, the difficult part of mediation is that you can’t put a price on life, really. What does it mean that you won’t see your child grow up now? How can anyone say “that’s worth this many dollars”? They can’t. To be blunt, here’s what mediation can’t give you:
- Justice
- Vindication
- Satisfaction
- Closure
That may sound odd for a professional mediator to say, but think about: all of those things are invisible, and a mixture of ideas and feelings. They’re closely connected to what you think and how you feel about what has happened (and may still be happening) to you. Dealing with them, processing them, living with and through them: these things take time, personal work and often therapy. Healing is your work, the goal before you, whatever the injury.
So why even go through mediation? Because often healing is protracted, and recovering from catastrophes doesn’t happen overnight. Moreover, your earning potential can be affected, and treatment – whether physical or psychological – is not cheap, particularly when extended. What mediation gives you is the best shot at securing the means to offset the cost of your recovery.
But I learned that even those suffering from terrible tragedy don’t want or need me to act sad when I’m around them. If anything, doing so may actually make them feel worse. The last thing I want to do is add to the burden they feel.
So when you meet me, you’ll find that I’m both considerate and also essentially a happy person. I’m not here to be anything but who I am for you in this moment of pain, and to bring the full set of my skills and expertise to bear on the challenge of mediation.
Because when I enter a mediation I have one goal: to get you the highest number the people on the other side of the table are willing to agree to. That’s what I do best. In fact, it’s the only thing I bring to the situation.
Now, I am very good at it. I think you’ll be hard-pressed to find someone else with the combination of know-how, tenacity and patience I bring to the negotiating table. I’ve got this. What that means is that you can leave that task in my hands.
And I know that sometimes, even if it’s not to the extent or degree you wish, some acknowledgement of the other party’s impact on your life can be a comfort on your road to healing. That can happen; it often does not, at least not verbally. So when you go into a day of mediation, try to remember the purpose of the session: it’s about getting you back up and stepping forward into life again.
I empathize deeply with the desire to do that. I’m eager and hungry to live my best life, and I’ll do anything in my power to give my clients the best shot at getting back to living theirs.
Part II: For Defendants
In Part 1 of this blog, I sketched out my approach to mediation from a plaintiff’s perspective. The goal was to show that in any situation I’m bringing my best to the table for you.
Let me be clear: that goes for both sides of the table. I wouldn’t be a mediator if I didn’t stand in the middle on behalf of both parties. Let’s start by acknowledging that though there are two sides to the mediation table, they are not similar in any way. The goals of a defendant, their approach to litigation, the significance of a lawsuit to a business entity, and even assessing risk and reward: they are all handled so differently by defendants as to be unrecognizable by plaintiffs.
And plaintiffs and defendants have very different motivations.
For a plaintiff, what has happened is (hopefully) a once-in-a-lifetime experience, and they have nothing to which to compare it. Even to speak of a settlement as if it is equivalent in some way to the pain they live with is unnatural, and this can affect their ability to trust in the process.
For a defendant – and here I mean a business, a corporation, an employer or similar – accidents of the sort that lead to litigation are part of doing business. That’s in no way meant to sound callous; it’s just that if you do a thing long enough, with enough people, and you grow, it’s almost a law of nature that accidents happen. As a business owner, it behooves you to plan for those moments with the help of experts. In addition to baseline data from specialists like actuaries, defendants often benefit most from reviewing legal precedence in like cases. What have settlements looked like in cases that could be classed as similar? What is the likely cost to resolve the problem as quickly and as effectively as possible?
I have been in rooms with one plaintiff and their lawyer; I have been in rooms where whole families show up, each member of which has an opinion about what their injured relative should receive. Sometimes their pastor shows up too, which creates yet another wrinkle in the approach. These folks often aren’t thinking of legal precedence, or of recent trends in settlements; they are quite understandably focused on their loss, and on what that loss means for their future.
My work as a mediator means I must translate the asks and the offers made by plaintiffs and defendants for and to one another, in language they understand and in terms they have some measure of agency to act on.
To that end, if you are a defendant in a case requiring mediation, here’s what you can expect from me:
- I will be a wise steward of your financial resources, and of your reputation.
- I will do my utmost to negotiate a fair, reasonable settlement given both the nature of the case and legal precedence.
- I will free you to focus on your goals for a settlement, and communicate the plaintiff’s perspective in terms that retain your agency and decision-making ability on behalf of your stakeholders. Because we are working together to find a settlement. That doesn’t mean one side wins while the other loses; it doesn’t mean one side walks away happy while the other grinds their teeth in despair. It means we find a place we can agree to call the matter resolved, so we can move on with our lives and our work.
I have been mediating with Henning since 2012. Whether you are a plaintiff or a defendant, I look forward to working with you.